National

SC rejects probe into alleged payoffs to Modi

Agency | January 11, 2017 07:51 PM

New Delhi : In a boost to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the Supreme Court on Wednesday rejected a plea to probe the alleged payoffs by the Birla-Sahara groups to him when he was the Gujarat Chief Minister.

Rejecting a plea by NGO Common Cause, Justice Arun Mishra and Justice Amitava Roy said the documents produced to seek an FIR against the Prime Minister and other political functionaries including government officials had no "evidentiary value."

"If we were to order investigation on the basis of material with no evidentiary value, it would be difficult for constitutional functionaries to function, which would not be safe for democracy," the court said.

"Given the shape in which these documents have been collected and filed, we are of the opinion that it would not be safe and proper to order investigation," the court said in its order while weighing the evidence in the context of earlier judgments of the apex court, including that of the Constitution Bench.

The judges said they were not doubting the decision of the Settlement Commission of the Income Tax department on the issue.

Both Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal had flashed what they said were Income Tax department documents to claim that Modi got huge sums of money as bribes when he presided over Gujarat.

Petitioner Prashant Bhushan said he was dismayed by the court ruling.

"It is not a blow to me but a blow to the people of the country," he told the media, adding "it is a blow to the reputation of the Supreme Court because today it has let down the people of the country."

Have something to say? Post your comment
Must Read
Former Mayor of Jalandhar, Surinder Mahey files nomination from Jalandhar (West) as  an Independent
Former Mayor of Jalandhar, Surinder Mahey files nomination from Jalandhar (West) as an Independent
 Importance of Blood Donation : Donate blood, stay healthy and save life!
Importance of Blood Donation : Donate blood, stay healthy and save life!
AAP expands organizational structure, appoints new office bearers
AAP expands organizational structure, appoints new office bearers
A PCS Officer transferred by Election Commission
Former General Secretary of SGPC, Sukhdev Singh Bhaur joins AAP
Former General Secretary of SGPC, Sukhdev Singh Bhaur joins AAP
AAP candidate Dr Sanjiv Sharma files nomination papers from the Jalandhar Central constituency
AAP candidate Dr Sanjiv Sharma files nomination papers from the Jalandhar Central constituency
Congress candidate from Jalandhar Central Rajinder Beri files nomination
Congress candidate from Jalandhar Central Rajinder Beri files nomination
Sukhbir Singh Badal announces Gurpartap Singh Tikka as party candidate from Amritsar South
Sukhbir Singh Badal announces Gurpartap Singh Tikka as party candidate from Amritsar South
SAD candidate Sarabjit Singh Makkar Files nomination from Jalandhar Cantonment constituency
SAD candidate Sarabjit Singh Makkar Files nomination from Jalandhar Cantonment constituency
Massive show of strength by Joginder Singh Mann during filing of nomination papers
Massive show of strength by Joginder Singh Mann during filing of nomination papers
AAP Candidate HS Walia files nomination from Jalandhar Cantt constituency
AAP Candidate HS Walia files nomination from Jalandhar Cantt constituency
AAP’s “Broom” is shown as election symbol for Independent Candidates in Jalandhar
AAP’s “Broom” is shown as election symbol for Independent Candidates in Jalandhar